Avoid using a Layer 3 multicast extended VLAN topology without SMLT.
Do not connect non-SMLT PIM routers in a linear fashion on the same VLAN. This topology is called an extended VLAN. Unlike a shared VLAN topology where all routers on the same VLAN are physically one hop away from each other, a VLAN router at one end of the extended VLAN has one or more routers in between it and the router at the far end of the extended VLAN. The following figure shows an extended VLAN.
In the preceding figure, all routers use PIM-SSM. The source connects to Router A on VLAN 10. All routers and receiver hosts connect on the same extended VLAN, VLAN 20. All routers have a receiver in VLAN 20. Router D is the PIM DR for VLAN 20 and the source host is not on VLAN 20. PIM-SSM does not require a Rendezvous Point (RP).
In this topology, each router receives an IGMP membership report from its local receiver host, and then sends a PIM SG join message towards the source on VLAN 20. VLAN flooding propagates the PIM SG join message through to Router A, the PIM DR for the source VLAN 10. Each router from Router D to Router A records a PIM join on the port on which the join message was received, and then sends out its own join message toward the source. Data then flows from the source to the receiver, as long as a join exists on those ports.
Because all routers are in the same VLAN 20, they receive joins from one another due to flooding in the VLAN. For example, Router D receives join messages from Router C on its port ‘b‘, and Router C receives join messages from Router B on its port toward Router B. On VSP 9000 Series routers, PIM join suppression is always enabled. In accordance with the PIM protocol rules, suppression causes Router D to stop sending a join towards the source because it receives a join for the same group and same RP on the port (port b) of the upstream neighbor (the router towards the source). Router D does not need to send a redundant join on the same VLAN. Router D stops sending a join, and the join that is recorded on port c of Router C eventually times out and is removed from the egress list of the (s,g) multicast route entry on Router C. This removal causes Router C to stop forwarding multicast traffic to Router D, and to the receiver (R1).
The purpose of join suppression is to suppress joins on a shared VLAN, such that if all routers on the shared VLAN want to receive data from the same RP and group, then only one of them needs to send the join on the VLAN. One join is enough to pull the data from the source router to the shared VLAN for all routers to receive. The other routers can suppress sending their own joins when they see such a join on the port toward the upstream router. In this way, less protocol message congestion exists in the shared VLAN. In the following figure, Router D sends the initial join message, which is seen by Router B and Router C. Router B and Router C suppress their own join messages. Router A (the PIM DR for the source VLAN 10) sends the data to VLAN 20, which is received by Routers B, C, and D due to the shared (non-extended) VLAN topology, and traffic is forwarded to all receiver hosts.
The extended VLAN topology looks exactly like the non-extended shared VLAN topology to the router, which cannot distinguish between the two.
In the current release, you cannot disable join suppression on a router. This enhancement will be added in a future release. Until this enhancement is included, you can perform the following actions:
Avoid this type of extended VLAN topology, and instead use Layer 3 routing between the routers. Do not extend VLAN 20 throughout, but rather, create a different VLAN between each router.
Configure the PIM DR for VLAN 20 to be the router closer to the source (Router B) so that any join received on the VLAN 20 DR (Router B) will be recorded as an IGMP local leaf on VLAN 20 as opposed to a PIM join, which does not time out until the receiver host stops sending IGMP membership reports.